American Idol - Open Letter to Carly Smithson
Posted in Commentary on April 24th, 2008 by admin
It seems we’ve been fighting to keep you in the contest since the beginning, and I’m sure you feel the same. For you it has gone on for a few years years, as first a visa was stopping you, and now it’s hard to figure out what it was that stopped you, but when it comes down to it, I think it was none other than trying too hard to be what you thought we wanted.
What we want, as American Idol fans, is for you to be yourself. We don’t want that diva-ish stuff you sang in the beginning, as you were hoping to show us your talent. We know you’re talented, and if you would have just sung stuff that meant something to you and/or that you had fun with, we all would have enjoyed ourselves much more, and in the process we would have found your talent.
From the very beginning I have sounded like a broken record as I begged you to sing music that is closer to your heritage. What I wouldn’t have given to hear you sing a Van Morrison tune. Since we’ve never heard any of his music on American Idol before, other than Jon Peter Lewis’ audition, I’m thinking the show can’t get clearance for his music. However, there has to be some Irish folk rock music somewhere you could have gotten your hands on. I think you would have brought the house down. Read more »
I have no idea why I was once again so short-sighted, but I have once ago bought decaffeinated tea. Why do I keep doing that to myself? Thankfully, today is such a gorgeous day out there that that alone is keeping me awake. Before I go out and enjoy the day, let’s dish a little.
I think tonight was pretty deliberate of The Powers That Be at American Idol. After they surprisingly lost yet another guy last week in Michael Johns, well before his time, leaving them with just three guys, and four girls whom many think have lesser talent to the remaining guys, they’re stuck with a pre-planned Mariah Carey week. And it’s well-known that the first performer every night is in a very vulnerable position, while the last position is the most charmed, as that’s the one people are left with. So let’s examine the order and what we are left with.
Right now my face looks like Paula Abdul’s, with my chin literally on the ground. I was hoping you’d make it to final three, but I wasn’t too sure. Regardless, I never would have thought you’d go this early. I thought for sure you’d be here until at least final five or six. This has me absolutely blindsided.
Last year’s Idol Gives Back extravaganza had a specialness that seemed to be lacking in the show from last night, but I can’t seem to put my finger on exactly what was missing. It had all the star power of the last and just as many sad stories, but it didn’t feel the same. I didn’t jump off the couch last night aching to do something to help.
It’s an interesting assignment American Idol had this week, finding inspirational songs. It seems to mean something slightly different to everyone. While last year many of the Idols relied on songs of the overall theme, such as making the world better, and a few looked at personal inspiration, nearly all the Idols tonight looked at personal inspiration. A few of them still didn’t seem to get it, and some you would think would struggle did quite well.
As if we needed further proof after last night of Dolly Patron’s talent, it was her music this week that finally weeded out some of the talent that was a little overdue in leaving. The Beatles music couldn’t do it, and neither could music from the year they were born, but Dolly could.
… I never promised you a rose garden.
Claudette Yamin is a pseudo celebrity because of her dedication to following her son’s career. She seemed to be a permanent fixture in the American Idol audience during season 5. Watching her ride in the motorcade with her son during his “home” visit as final three, nobody could be more proud.
I was kind of hoping while I was on vacation that the celebrities would behave themselves, but of course this didn’t totally happen. I could sit here this morning and do a bunch of April Fool’s posts, but I’m not one to start gossip, just spread it. So, let’s dish a little.
To settle another thing keeping me up at night, Jennifer Love Hewitt is not PG. She was attacked for wearing a bikini without having a totally svelte figure before, and when she’s wearing the style of tops that are now in, blousy things that are loose in the midriff, everyone calls her pregnant. It can’t be easy. Jen, women across America can certainly sympathize with you, and if they’re the ones criticizing, shame on them.

