With an American Idol season that started out with so much hope, it just seems to get more and more weird the further we get into it. The surprising eliminations just don’t stop, and there are plenty of other oddities to go along with it. All this after the show had promised changes for the better this time after a very lackluster final two of Jordin Sparks and Blake Lewis.
With Rock ‘n Roll Hall of Fame music, I figured it would be a fantastic week! Well, they got rid of some of the best rock ‘n rollers on the show too early for that. If we were going to do rock ‘n roll, shouldn’t we have Michael Johns, Carly Smithson, Brooke White, and even Chikezie and Amanda Overmeyer? Now that would be a good show! But they were taken down too early by The Beetles, inspirational music, songs from the years they were born, and Neil Diamond, waiting to get the chance to sing the greatest rock ‘n roll that ever was.
So here’s what our final four chooses to sing in a week to showcase how well they can rock it out. Duran Duran, Tina Turner, Bob Marley, Ben E. King, The Who, Sam Cooke, Bob Dylan, and Elvis Presley. There isn’t anything wrong with these selections, but together as a whole, it leaves you scratching your head. The only one that had me rocking was Baba O’Reilly. I certainly wasn’t rocking to the way David Archuleta arranged his songs into ballads.
And just what is up with Jason Castro. He’s been very unprepared the past three weeks, the first of which he was forced into singing Memory from Cats. It’s like he realized no matter what he did, American Idol was not going to allow him to win. Almost as if he figured why bother. Then it all got much worse for him last week when Paula trashed his second performance before he even did it. That must have felt great walking onstage to.
Who leaves tonight is a mystery to me, but it has to be either Jason or Syesha. She’s been in the bottom three so often, she’ll very likely end up there again. While she’s been better than Jason the past few weeks, I think you have to judge on the whole season. But if people are only judging on last night, it could very well be him. Either way, with them as the bottom two, Simon will tell America they got it right, and Paula will go on and on about it being the beginning of their careers. Randy will just tell Dawg, gee, he just doesn’t know what to think.
And after last night and the season as a whole that we’ve had … I don’t know what to think either.
Photos Courtesy of americanidol.com
For more information on American Idol, see SirLinksalot: American Idol, and for a recap of Tuesday night’s performances, see Reality Shack.